Calabash style isn’t a franchise or a chain. It’s a way of cooking seafood that was born right here in Calabash — and if you grew up around here, you’ve been eating it your whole life.
It starts with fresh shrimp, flounder, oysters, scallops or clam strips, given a light dusting of seasoned flour and cornmeal — never a thick, heavy batter — and fried in small batches, hot and fast, for about two minutes, until golden and crisp. The seafood is the star, not the coating. It comes with hushpuppies and coleslaw, most often piled on a combination platter built for sharing.
The story starts in the 1930s, when fishing families held oyster roasts along the Calabash River. In 1940, Lucy Coleman opened Coleman’s Original, the town’s first seafood restaurant, dipping her catch in evaporated milk, then seasoned flour and cornmeal, before it hit the fryer. Her sister Ruth Beck opened Beck’s around the same time — the two families still argue, fondly, over who was first — and their brother Lawrence and his wife Ella opened Ella’s in 1950. By 1954 the little fishing village had three restaurants, and it was on its way to calling itself the Seafood Capital of the World.
You can still eat the real thing today. Beck’s Restaurant, at 1014 River Road, is still run by the family. The Calabash Seafood Hut, at 1125 River Road, has been frying since 1968, built by Virgil “Tinkey” Coleman, Lucy’s son, and still run by his family. Captain Nance’s, on Nance Street along the river, has served the same recipe from the same spot since Lennon Nance built it in 1975.
Two of the old names are gone for now: Coleman’s Original was sold in 2017, and The Oyster Rock stands on its waterfront site today. Fire destroyed Ella’s in 2023, and the family plans to rebuild it.
Legend has it comedian Jimmy Durante ate in Calabash in the 1940s and started closing his radio and TV shows with “Goodnight, Mrs. Calabash, wherever you are.” Most folks around here will tell you Mrs. Calabash was Lucy Coleman herself.
If you’re new to the coast, start with a combination platter and bring an appetite. And if you’ve been eating Calabash style all your life — what’s your order: flounder, shrimp, oysters, or the whole platter?
(Sources: NC’s Brunswick Islands; Our State magazine; Southern Foodways Alliance)
Photo: 3 Lees Travel Adventures

Leave a Reply